Daniel Willingham--Science & Education
Hypothesis non fingo
  • Home
  • About
  • Books
  • Articles
  • Op-eds
  • Videos
  • Learning Styles FAQ
  • Daniel Willingham: Science and Education Blog

Failure to Replicate Values Affirmation as an Countermeasure to Stereotype Threat.

9/6/2016

 

Research over the last 20 years has shown that at least part of the academic problems children show in school are not wholly academic; some difficulties are rooted in self-image. Students may be hobbled by their perception of themselves as not fitting an academic context.

More pernicious, that threat to social identity can be cast on the student. That’s the heart of stereotype threat (Steele & Aronson, 1995). When a student who belongs to a group stereotyped as low-performing is asked to accomplish an academic task, he or she feels anxious, and his or her thoughts are preoccupied with concern about fulfilling the stereotype. Those thoughts occupy working memory, and the student is, indeed, less able to perform the task. The student doesn’t need to endorse the stereotype to feel its effects; worrying about fulfilling the stereotype that others hold is enough.

Geoff Cohen (Cohen et al, 2006) came up with a strategy to combat the problem. Students complete brief writing exercises that require them to think about personal values, things that are important in their lives. The subject might be friends, family, music, sports, politics, whatever. The idea is that stereotype threat situations narrow the sense of self—suddenly, an African-American boy sees himself as nothing but “kid who is not supposed to succeed in math.” The writing exercises are supposed to remind him that he’s much more than that, and so feel less threatened.

Some early experiments showed that several such writing exercises over the course of a school year (each taking just 20 minutes) had a substantial impact on academic achievement for 7th grade African-American and Hispanic students, presumably through the reduction of stereotype threat, and perhaps through other mechanisms.

Despite early successes, recent attempts to replicate the intervention are failing.

The most recent (Hanselman et al 2016) tested nearly 500 middle school students, and attempted to replicate closely the original methods used by Cohen. This graph summarizes effect sizes of the intervention on GPA from different studies. Note that the larger effect sizes come from studies with smaller Ns.

Picture
Error bars are 95% confidence intervals. Dotted line is weighted mean.
What are we to make of this?

Hanselman and colleagues suggest that the intervention may be sensitive to various modifying variables and presumably, it will be difficult identify and measure them all, casting doubt on the utility of the writing exercises in schools. (They were able to test the impact of some moderators that current theory would predict was important--they seemed not to matter.)

For my part, I’ve always found it difficult to understand why the intervention worked in the first place. Why would a writing intervention influence sense of self months later? Sense of self Is surely the product of many experiences over a long time, and there’s no reason to suspect that the stereotype-threat situations would trigger a memory of the writing exercise and thus influence sense of self at that moment.

The writing sounds sort of similar to one I blogged about recently—having college freshman watch videos of older student describing their experiences from freshman year, and then writing about the videos. The important difference is that the target was not students’ sense of self (which I’m suggesting is robust and hard to change) but their sense of what college is like, which, I would expect, would be less closely held and more easily influenced.

The door is not closed on the values affirmation intervention, but much work is to be done if it is to prove useful in schools.

Comments are closed.

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

    RSS Feed


    Purpose

    The goal of this blog is to provide pointers to scientific findings that are applicable to education that I think ought to receive more attention.

    Archives

    April 2022
    July 2020
    May 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    December 2019
    October 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    January 2019
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    June 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    November 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    December 2015
    July 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    January 2015
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012

    Categories

    All
    21st Century Skills
    Academic Achievement
    Academic Achievement
    Achievement Gap
    Adhd
    Aera
    Animal Subjects
    Attention
    Book Review
    Charter Schools
    Child Development
    Classroom Time
    College
    Consciousness
    Curriculum
    Data Trustworthiness
    Education Schools
    Emotion
    Equality
    Exercise
    Expertise
    Forfun
    Gaming
    Gender
    Grades
    Higher Ed
    Homework
    Instructional Materials
    Intelligence
    International Comparisons
    Interventions
    Low Achievement
    Math
    Memory
    Meta Analysis
    Meta-analysis
    Metacognition
    Morality
    Motor Skill
    Multitasking
    Music
    Neuroscience
    Obituaries
    Parents
    Perception
    Phonological Awareness
    Plagiarism
    Politics
    Poverty
    Preschool
    Principals
    Prior Knowledge
    Problem-solving
    Reading
    Research
    Science
    Self-concept
    Self Control
    Self-control
    Sleep
    Socioeconomic Status
    Spatial Skills
    Standardized Tests
    Stereotypes
    Stress
    Teacher Evaluation
    Teaching
    Technology
    Value-added
    Vocabulary
    Working Memory